A History of Salem's Horror House

The Crowninshield- Bentley house is steeped in Salem's history as well as the setting for a horror story by a master of terror, H.P.Lovecraft.

In the early 1600s, Johann Caspar Richter moved from Denmark to the town of Kronenschieldt in Upper Saxony (present Germany) and married Maria Hahn.

The family then added the town’s name to their own. Their son Johannes Caspar Richter von Kronenschieldt, after being educated in Leipzig, moved to Boston around 1688.

Arriving in this English-speaking area, he anglicized his name to John Caspar Crowninshield. In 1694 he married Elizabeth Allen, the daughter of a ship captain. They lived near Spring Pond that was the border between Lynn and Salem. Little did they realize that they were the beginnings of a family dynasty that would stretch through generations of power and influence in Salem and beyond. Their family would be included in the listing of America’s most powerful families and be considered one of the original Boston Brahmins.

The first native born generation sought and found their livelihood and growing fortune pursuing life in the growing port of Salem. John Crowninshield, achieving some success as a fish merchant and ship captain, built the above modest house at 106 Essex St. It was here that four generations of the Crowninshield Family lived. As the family fortune grew throughout the 18th century from the spice and far east trade as well as privateering during the Revolution, other mansions were built, but this house remained in the family.

The Crowninshield family, thanks to their trading expertise, became one of the wealthiest families of Salem. George Crowninshield (1733-1815) founded the Crowninshield & Sons Shipping Company with his five sons. They built the Crowninshield Wharf, (where the power plant is now) that serviced the far east trade. It was Captain Jacob Crowninshield, one of George’s sons, who purchased in India the first elephant brought to America. When he did so he wrote that he had used his own money, $450, to make the purchase and if it was a folly it was his alone. He later sold the elephant in New York for $10,000. The elephant was a spectacular hit as it toured the country.

While there was competition and some antipathy, especially regarding politics, among Salem’s elite, wealthy families, they shared the same society. That closeness produced a number of intermarriages. The Crowninshield family intermarried with the Derby, Endicott, Gardner, Peabody and Pickman families over the years. As shipping waned, successive generations became involved in government, the arts, and a number of charitable enterprises.

Over the generations, the family has produced a number of state representatives, senators, congressmen and cabinet members under Presidents Jefferson, Monroe, Madison, Cleveland and Hoover. There were also a number of Generals and Admirals in the armed forces. In the arts, the family has produced notable painters and craftsmen.

Reverend William Bentley, the pastor of the East Church and noted Diarist of Salem during the East India Trade, boarded with the Crowninshield family from 1791 to his sudden death in 1819. At this time Hannah, the widow of Jacob Crowninshield, to make ends meet, was taking in boarders in her half of the house that had been divided at John’s death. The other half of the house was owned by her son, Benjamin, who, as a ship captain and merchant, was very successful. His half of the house was expanded and rennovated during his tenure.

Rev. Bentley’s 11-volume, (abridged), diary is still a popular source of everyday knowledge of the town of Salem and its people at the height of the East India trade. He was a noted scholar and frequent correspondent to Thomas Jefferson, often translating and advising. Jefferson tried to recruit him as the first president of University of Virginia as well as Chaplain to the Congress. Bentley declined both offers in favor of staying in his much loved Salem. His room was on the right hand end of the second floor. When the house was on Essex Street, his view looked down Union Street toward the old bridge.

By mid 19th century, most of the Crowninshield family had moved from Salem to Boston as well as New Hampshire, Vermont and New York where they became involved in local and state affairs and are often commemorated by streets named after the family.

Over the next several decades the house changed hands. Through most of the 19th century, the house remained a residence nestled behind the Franklin Building that housed the East India Marine Society that the Crowninshields helped to found. In 1924, The Franklin Building was replaced by the Hawthorne Hotel.

In 1884, Miss E.B. Day adapted the house to have a variety store at what was then 110 Essex St. In 1897, James and Mary Flynn took over the building and store, making it Mary Flynn’s Millinery Store.

The Mary Flynn Millinery store at 108 Essex St. was here until 1949 when the store was briefly Rose Haddad’s jacket store. In 1950 it became Moulton’s Bakery and Pastry Shoppe. The end of the bakery in 1958-1959 corresponded to the Hawthorne Hotel’s purchase of the property to expand their parking lot. then donated the building to the Essex Institute, which moved the house across the street to 126 Essex St. on the corner lot where it remains. Once there, it was restored and became part of the Essex Institute's historic properties.

During the time the house was still at 108 Essex St. it became the focus of the noted horror and fantasy writer H.P. Lovecraft, (1890-1937). Lovecraft, perhaps drawing on his mother’s heritage as a descendant of George Phillips who landed in Salem in 1630, sited many of his stories in the fictional town of Arkham which most scholars believe was based on Salem.

While Lovecraft was born in Providence, RI, and spent most of his life there, he did travel throughout New England and no doubt visited Salem.
The names of his characters draw heavily on old Salem names such as Crowninshield, Derby and Pickman. His story, “The Thing on the Doorstep” is believed to take place in the Crowninshield-Bentley House. At the H.P. Lovecraft website there is a guide to the settings of his stories that points to several Salem sites.  

While Lovecraft only enjoyed limited commercial success during his lifetime, in successive years, his reputation and stature as an influential and talented writer has grown. Stephen King, the best-selling author, characterized Lovecraft as "the twentieth century's greatest practitioner of the classic horror tale,” and credited him as the single greatest influence on his writing.

In 2006, the house was closed to the public so that a four-year restoration could be accomplished. The house was restored to its 1797 appearance when the Crowninshield family and Rev. Bentley lived there. This painstaking restoration used state of the art techniques to re-create the colors and layout of the house. They then furnished it with period furniture from the museum’s extensive collections. The final phase of this restoration was the recreation of Rev. Bentley’s library and study in his rooms.

This house is currently part of a three-house tour offered by the and well worth a visit.

Donovan K. Loucks August 24, 2012 at 05:21 PM
An excellent article on a great old house! I last toured it about a decade ago and am looking forward to doing so again now that the restoration is complete. Philip A. Shreffler (in his The H.P. Lovecraft Companion) was probably the first to posit the notion that Lovecraft based the Crowninshield House in "The Thing on the Doorstep" on the Crowninshield-Bentley House. However, I've come to the conclusion that Lovecraft was just "draw[ing] heavily on old Salem names", as Mr. Curley writes. Although the house now occupies a very prominent location -- which is no doubt part of the reason Shreffler chose it -- its location and function in Lovecraft's time was far less notable. In his letters, Lovecraft mentions over a dozen houses in Salem, including the Elias Haskett Derby house, but never the Crowninshield-Bentley House (or any other Crowninshield house). Regardless, I think viewing houses like the Crowninshield-Bentley House are important to understanding the atmosphere that Lovecraft was creating in his stories. But rather than focusing on specific houses, I think it's better to experience Salem as Lovecraft did: roaming the streets, soaking up the atmosphere, and exploring museum houses as the fancy strikes you. Still, I probably should update that page on The H.P. Lovecraft Archive... Donovan K. Loucks Webmaster, The H.P. Lovecraft Archive http://www.hplovecraft.com
Dawn Cerbone August 24, 2012 at 06:03 PM
I would take that tour even though I never read his books. It would show Salem through the eyes of someone else.
Jerome Curley August 25, 2012 at 05:31 AM
Thanks Donovan for your thoughts and insights. I agree that it's the atmosphere that counts. I found it interesting that the period when Lovecraft was a Salem visitor was a time before modern restorations and many an old house had been re-worked, fading or hiding its former appearance heightening the notion that buildings were hidden within buildings. Your H.P. Lovecraft Archive is an excellent site and well worth visiting to learn about a great American writer. It was the catylist for my re-reading H.P. Lovecraft stories from my college days. Thank you for your work in maintaining the site.
Erin M August 25, 2012 at 09:54 PM
We did the 3 house tour over the fourth of July this yr and we enjoyed every minute of it.
Donovan K. Loucks September 06, 2012 at 12:28 AM
You're very welcome, Jerome! Thanks for the compliments, for your excellent article, and for that 1891 photo of the house! You're absolutely right about how "buildings were hidden within buildings". A perfect example of that is the Jonathan Corwin/Witch House, which in Lovecraft's time was covered with a gambrel roof and fronted by a drug store! So many people are convinced inspired Lovecraft's "The Dreams in the Witch House", but back in Lovecraft's time no one could've been inspired by it! Donovan K. Loucks Webmaster, The H.P. Lovecraft Archive http://www.hplovecraft.com


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »